• 구독신청
  • My스크랩
  • 지면신문
FNTIMES 대한민국 최고 금융 경제지
ad

Doosan Enerbility, Rebuts Recommendation Against ISS Split-off Merger

신혜주 기자

hjs0509@fntimes.com

기사입력 : 2024-12-04 10:44 최종수정 : 2024-12-04 10:50

"Strengthening Major Shareholder Control, Not a Transaction for Profit"
Risks Exist, such as Sale of Bobcat, Rejection of Business Combination Approval
Bobcat comparisons to peers in Japan and China are not valid

Doosan Enerbility, Rebuts Recommendation Against ISS Split-off Merger이미지 확대보기
[Korea Financial Times, Shin Haeju] As Doosan Enerbility prepares to hold an extraordinary general meeting of shareholders to approve the proposed spin-off merger with Doosan Robotics on the 12th, Doosan Enerbility Chief Financial Officer (CFO) and CEO Park Sang-Hyun has released the second and third shareholder letters.

While the second shareholder letter contained the advantages of the spin-off merger that has been revealed so far, the third shareholder letter contained a rebuttal to the proxy exercise recommendation published by ISS (Institutional Shareholder Services), the world's largest proxy advisory firm. On the 28th of last month, ISS advised investors to oppose the 'Approval of the Spin-off Merger Agreement' that Doosan Enerbility had submitted as an agenda item for the extraordinary general meeting of shareholders.

CEO Park Sang-hyun said, "ISS's analysis contains significant errors and one-sided claims that do not match the facts," and "We found more than 10 errors, large and small, in the ISS report."

Park criticized, "ISS pointed out that this transaction was not reviewed by a special committee comprised only of outside directors, despite the fact that it involved a conflict of interest between the majority and minority shareholders, but this is due to ignorance of Korean commercial law."

According to the Commercial Law, a spin-off merger that requires approval from a general shareholders' meeting cannot be delegated to a committee within the board of directors, and the board of directors must directly resolve it and propose it to the general shareholders' meeting. It is impossible for a special committee, not the board of directors, to deliberate and decide on this transaction.

He said, "This spin-off merger is not a transaction to strengthen the control or profit of major shareholders," and "The only difference is which affiliate Doosan Bobcat becomes a subsidiary of, but the control is the same."

He added, “On the contrary, Doosan's voting rights in Doosan Robotics will be diluted from 68% to 57%, and there will be no dividend or other benefit to Doosan from the transaction.”

▲Park Sang-hyun, CEO of Doosan Enerbility

▲Park Sang-hyun, CEO of Doosan Enerbility

Regarding the choice of a complex spin-off merger transaction rather than a simple cash transaction, he said, "In the current business environment, the speed and timing of investment are more important than the amount of Doosan Bobcat's stake sale, so a spin-off merger that guarantees certainty and speed of the transaction is the best option."

In the case of Doosan Bobcat, since most of its business sites are overseas, considering the size of its sales, it is necessary to report business combinations in more than 10 countries. It is difficult to predict when approval will be completed. There is also a risk that approval may be rejected depending on who the buyer is. For example, in the case of Korean Air and Asiana Airlines, which are currently in the process of merging, it took about 4 years to get approval for the overseas business combination.

Park said, "Considering the down cycle of Doosan Bobcat's business, the delay in the sale period or the success of the sale is even more uncertain," and "The success rate of recent M&A cases is around 20%."

In response to the suggestion that Doosan Bobcat is undervalued compared to other Asian peers, Mr. Lee emphasized that “the companies listed in the ISS report are not peers in terms of their focus, geography and size.

It is not reasonable to conclude that Doosan Bobcat is undervalued by directly comparing the value ratios of Doosan Bobcat and its Asian peers without considering the specifics of each market.

In the case of Chinese companies, it was pointed out that the domestic economic stimulus policy has a significant impact on sales growth and that it is an industry practice to exclude them from the same industry because the market characteristics are significant. It is also necessary to consider the fact that the domestic stock market itself is undervalued compared to the Japanese and Chinese markets.

Park said, "It is questionable whether the ISS dissenting opinion written based on incorrect facts can guarantee credibility."

Currently, Doosan Enerbility is proposing a merger ratio of 1 to 0.043 for Doosan Robotics and the new corporation of Doosan Enerbility that owns Doosan Bobcat.

Shin Haeju (hjs0509@fntimes.com)

데일리 금융경제뉴스 FNTIMES - 저작권법에 의거 상업적 목적의 무단 전재, 복사, 배포 금지
Copyright ⓒ 한국금융신문 & FNTIMES.com

가장 핫한 경제 소식! 한국금융신문의 ‘추천뉴스’를 받아보세요~

KFT Topic 다른 기사

1 LS Cable & System Unit Gaon Cable Turns Exporter as AI Boom Lifts Nine-Month Sales Abroad Past Last Year’s Total Editor’s Note: As investment in artificial intelligence (AI) data centers and power grids grows, the wire and cable industry is drawing attention. LS Cable & System is strengthening the competitiveness of its subsidiaries and accelerating its push into global markets. Gaon Cable is transforming itself into an export-driven company, centered on the North American market, while its U.S. production unit LSCUS is expanding on the back of power demand from AI data centers. LS Marine Solution and LS Eco Energy are also securing new growth engines through submarine cables and operations in Vietn 2 Hanwha Solutions’ Pretax Profit Owes to Asset Sale, Not Core Business Hanwha Solutions’ third-quarter pretax profit turned positive, but the driver was not its core business. It was a single asset sale. The company sold intangible assets with a book value of KRW 12.5 billion and booked a gain of KRW 199.7 billion. Without that gain, this year’s third quarter would show a pretax loss of KRW 176.3 billion.The proceeds from the disposal differ by only KRW 0.8 billion from the amount of fixed assets Hanwha Solutions sold to TransGrid Energy, a Hanwha Group affiliate, over the same period. TransGrid Energy is a subsidiary of a joint venture in which Hanwha Solution 3 Lotte Chemical Pays Down JV Debt With KRW 600 Billion as Its Own Loans Get a Three-Year Reprieve Lotte Chemical contributed KRW 600 billion to help its joint venture H&L Advanced repay existing borrowings. But it has also taken on an impairment loss on its JV shares and faces additional funding support obligations. The value of the shares recognized in the merger-date accounting was less than half the per-share value assessed by an external valuation firm when the merger ratio was set. While pouring large sums into improving the JV’s finances, Lotte Chemical itself has agreed with its creditors to a three-year deferral of repayment on its covenant debt.According to the Financial Supe
ad
ad
ad

한국금융 포럼 사이버관

더보기

FT카드뉴스

더보기
[카드뉴스] 서울에서 떠나는 6000년 시간여행, 강동선사문화축제
[카드뉴스] 강감찬을 만나는 가을, 낙성대로!
[카드뉴스] 새우젓 따라 만나는 옛 마포나루
[카드뉴스] 성북동 언덕길, 만해의 집을 만나다
[카드뉴스] 약재 향 따라 걷는 서울약령시

FT도서

더보기